IMO a 23hp surface drive air cooled mud motor would work best for load carry and fuel economy and be able to take you into shallow waters where the fish are. The surface drive mudmotors offer resonable speed and ease of operation in the rough stuff and are easily maintained. Most use Vtwin rider mower motors. Been running a Mudbuddy since 2005 and have 355hrs on it, Check them out on their webb site at MudBuddy Motors to watch their videos and see their product line.